Where to start? I loved both graphic novels for different reasons. In terms of something good they both did, I loved that each one still took the subject matter seriously. Not that there isn't a time and place for fun, goofy, spin-offs, but I think I prefer a graphic novel to take itself seriously. This is partially because I think a heightened sense of melodrama is part of what makes graphic novels so great; if they are effective, you the reader can buy into it and transport yourself for a while.
Personally, I enjoyed the art style of Frankenstein's Womb more. I loved that the monster was simultaneously hideous and awe inspiring. Beautiful by no means, but well adapted to the graphic novel form (apparently Frankenstein had him on a low-carb diet in order to get him that six pack). I also think the choice to use black and white worked very well; it helped the transition from old text to graphic novel run much more smoothly.
Both of the graphic novels were awesome the graphics in both novels intensify this creepy eerie vibe that goes hand in hand when you think of Frankenstein. I think that the dramatic dark contrasts along with intense definitions in settings and weird angels draw the reader even more into the novel. I too, think that Frankenstein womb had a much greater appealing to me especially because of the colors, graphics and dramatic feel.
ReplyDelete